Wednesday, 9 December 2009

Chris Fonteijn, OPTA vision on infrastructure and next generation networks (fixed and mobile)

I start with some propositions. Propositions are never fully true, but that will lead to debate.
1. We’re doing very well in The Netherlands
2. FTTH is only used for downloading of movies and music and there are no services available for it
3. Municipalities should only facilitate the FTTH roll out and not invest in it.
The Netherlands is leading Europe in broadband connections. The price for broadband internet have dropped with84%. According to the OECD we’re the cheapest country in the world with regards to mobile bundles. Bundling is very important in the Netherlands. With FTTH we see steady growth and Reggefiber has 388.000 connections. We believe that the market has the primacy. The market delivers new innovation. Even though market is a dirty word at the moment.
If you look at competition in The Netherlands. We have always focussed on infrastructure competition. There has been some evolution in our thinking. The Commission started with the ladder of investment. New entrants would grow and would roll out multiple networks to the end-user. We do see that this vision hasn’t become reality. And we do believe that 2 is not enough. Having just cable and KPN is not enough for the market. Access regulation has served us well with KPN. We will look at cable too. We want to give investors long term regulatory certainty.
The future is bundling. We haven’t looked at bundling yet in our market analysis, but this will come. We expect in the future that content will become part of it too. We are concerned about the business market where KPN is still too large. With the Wholesale Cable regulation we want to give new entrants access to the analogue signal. This is still a very important competitive advantage for the cable networks. With fibre we want an open network, but have also seen that it isn’t going as fast as we had expected. This however isn’t our concern.
We do see a roll for the government in FTTH but it should be very limited. They should only facilitate. Competition should be the idea. Competition is the reason we have Docsis 3. Competition is why KPN works with Reggefiber. I do wonder what the consumer will benefit from fiber. We haven’t seen much yet. We don’t care too much about the technology, but what the consumer will get. We do see fiber as an end play.
We understand fiber is a risky investment. As the first regulator in Europe we have given long term certainty to private operators. We don’t see a big roll for the government in  investing financially in the network. In the Netherlands competition is taking the lead and I don’t know if municipalities can accelerate growth. Governments can disrupt competition if they invest financially in new networks. We also wonder if private parties don’t profit too much from governments cooperating with them. Profit too much compared to other existing parties. We expect much from competition. Combined with our regulation and local governments making FTTH roll out easy. I do believe we have created the right conditions and the business now will have to do it.

Ed Achterberg on what happened in 2009 in the Dutch Telecom Scene.

Ed Achterberg on what happened in 2009 in the Dutch Telecom Scene.

Growth has gone out of the broadband market. FTTH is growing slowsly. DSL has lost its steam and Cable has taken the initiative. DSL can only compet on price or on extra services. KPN is doubting between dSL and Fiber. On December 15th KPN will announce what she will do with DSL or Fiber.
UPC and Ziggo are offering the fastest speeds and DSL is the slowest technology. Also because the advertised speeds are up-to 20mbit/s. Glass fiber is out of this chart as the average speed is much higher than the 3 mbit/s max limited. 40% of the installed base of Cable is stuck already. If they go DSL they go back in speed and functionality.
The service revenue for mobile seems completely insensitive to the crisis. It seems to be… But is it really stable at 1,6 billion euro. KPN has slightly below 50%. It can’t become more or the OPTA will get mad and it won’t become less because KPN doesn’t want less. The total amount of active SIMS is much higher than our stats, because only KPN reports on its M2M installed base. ARPU is a very bad metric. What the consumer is paying for prepay is twice as much as what the operators are reporting as ARPU. The consumer is paying 12 euro, the telco reports 6, because of the amount of inactive SIMS. About 15% of the consumers have a databundle. And we see a growth.
Nokia is declining fast in the handset market. The Blackberry has become very popular with the youth segment. Blackberries can send free SMS’s called pings. Kids love those! Nokia has lost 25% of its market share in the Netherlands. From 42% to 34%.
In the television market we see that KPN’s Digitenne is flat. IPTV over DSL grows slowly. The wholesale offer analogue cable is an interesting proposition for Tele2. Television over Fiber is still difficult as many people keep their cable connection because of the abundance of channels and content and people only use fiber to connect to the net and telephony. HDTV is a great product and gives very little extra revenue. The average customer with an HDTV is willing to pay 3 euro extra for HDTV. Those without an HDTV capable tv are only willing to pay 1.50 euro.
Question: The Netherlands is the world leader in MVNO’s. What do you see there?
We see that everyone moves to smart pricing (making the contracts less transparent to the customer) For MVNO there is an opportunity there. MVNO’s can only distinguish themselves if they do more than just being cheaper. They could offer pico-cells.

Telecom Tim 09: Keynote Job Witteman on AMS-IX and growth

Job Witteman, Oei ik Groei…

Oops, I’m growing. Our growth shows the traditional hockeystick. In the summer we see a decrease in our growth. After the summer, when it’s cold our growth continues. Our IXP offers ISPS a neutral environment to interconnect their IP traffic. It’s a physical infrastructure where the ISP connects his network too.
ISP’s need to make their own peering agreements with other parties. The IXP itself isn’t a party in that deal. We don’t define what an ISP is, this has opened up our IXP to content providers like the public broadcasters and also the likes of Google. Traditionally the iXPisn’t used for exchanging Transit deals, but we don’t prohibit that. Peering is really a bilateral arrangement. My traffic to your network and your traffic to my network. It’s limited to that network. The IXP is neutral. We only charge for the port and we don’t take a fee per costs.
AMS-IX is the biggest with 846 Gbps and 54% growth. Moscow is smaller, but has 200% growth. The top 3 IXP’s take 60% of the traffic. The next 5 take 20% and the following 11 take 13%. Being big is an advantage. It draws more customers, which attract more customers still.
We’re an association, with a limited corporation. Everyone connected is a member of the association. Every member has one vote. There is a board with 5 members and 2 times a year there is a general meeting. In those meetings we vote for board members and the Long Term Commercial Plan.
All the stock in the limited corporation is owned by the association and can’t be sold. The limited corporation owns all assets, but it only lives to serve the association.
Basic values are:
-          Neutral and independent,
-          Democratic and open
-          Reliable
-          Continuity
-          Leading edge technology
-          Dynamic
-          Not-for-profit
Our core switches can work with 128 10Gbit/s ports at non-blocking speeds.
3 interconnect options:
-          Transit (also known as upstream). Can be quite expensive
-          Private interconnect
-          Public peering over IXP’s
Most ISP’s make use of a mix.

Carriers and mobile interconnects
IP convergence in the 2 world. Mobile operators are united/associated in a separate VLAN on the AMS-IX infrastructure for GRX roaming. There is a strict separation with the internet. There is a Closed User Group with its own agreements.
My first statement is:
-          Mobile internet is an illusion.
-          Mobile internet is a goldmine for the Mobile operators. Mobile telco’s don’t need to do anything for their customer. At 10 euro per month this can be as much 100 million per month in the Netherlands. You can build a nice network for that.
-          Video is not disruptive and will nog give you an exaflood, it’s normal growth and business as usual.
The growth at the GRX V-Lan is now around 100%. It used to be 1000%. We expect more growth if the mobile telco’s connect to the ISP VLAN and interconnect directly.
Question XS4All, where is there a possibility for disruption. Job explains about how well they organized everything redundantly.

Blogging from TelecomTime

I am at Telecomtime and blogging in the usual very rough way that I have done at previous conferences.

Monday, 7 December 2009

Dutch Cable grows faster than DSL and KPN is in trouble

KPN is in serious trouble in the Dutch broadband market. Telecompaper published the numbers and KPN is losing customers. Cable is winning, DSL is losing.  This may be surprising to some readers because:

  • KPN is one of the few incumbents that understood it needed to share its copper network with new entrants in order to defend against cable.
  • KPN made a good strategic move by entering into a joint venture with Reggefiber, thereby securing its access to FTTH, without serious impact on it's current balance sheet.
  • KPN had announced serious investement in VDSL2 and Fiber to the Curb in it's All-IP programme. It promised that by 2011 most of the country would have 50/50 VDSL2. 
  • KPN was on my Telecom Cool Wall for all of the above reasons
Unfortunately for KPN, there is a difference between strategy and execution.
  • This blog has pointed out in the past KPN's dismal FTTH and FTTC offer. 
  • Many of you also know that KPN has postponed most of its All-IP programme and will announce at the end of this year whether it goes for FTTH or FTTC. This while both UPC and Ziggo have upgraded their networks to Docsis 3.0 and are offering much higher speeds than KPN could dream about with any version of DSL. 
  • As of next year, KPN will offer VDSL2, but only from the central office. Almost all customers will get a speed increase, but most of them will not come close to the speeds VDSL2 could offer. 
  • KPN has offered no innovation in it's double play and triple play offer. Everything is basic and there are no extras, nothing unique. KPN's offer is below par. (74 euro per month for 20mbit/s, TV and local calling) Compare this to UPC, (74 euro for 60 mbit/s down 6 up, TV and europe wide calling --> cheaper options available too) 
Telecompaper published this quarters broadband numbers (ending September 30) and here are the results, there is a more extensive report, that you can purchase from them:
  • There are 5.996.000 broadband users in The Netherlands, this is up 38.300 from previous quarter
  • Cable has scooped up almost all those new subs. 
    • Ziggo took 18000 subs
    • UPC took 14500 subs
  • Fiber grew with 17,000 subs or 12% to 160,000 subscribers, most of them seem to come from DSL. 
  • DSL lost 12.700 subscribers or 0.4% of the market to 3.542 million
    • Tele2 did increase its subs with 15,000 net adds to 390,500 DSL subs
    • KPN subsidiary Het Net lost 11,000 subs
Even though I don't have the full report yet, this does suggest that KPN lost at least 27,000 subscribers and that almost all new subscribers to broadband either take cable or fibre.

What is KPN to do? An agressive lowering of prices doesn't seem to have much impact on switchers according to Ed Achterberg of Telecompaper. It's budget offer Telfort wasn't too succesful with that strategy Introducing a Free.fr type service innovation isn't part of KPN's DNA and will take at least two years to materialize, but could help it stem the bleeding. Short term, KPN could do a couple of things, that would raise it's profile in the market.
  • Open the customers wifi access points for other customers. 2.x million hotspots potentially. Dutch cable companies never integrated wifi with their cable modems, so they can't follow KPN there. Nice thing is it requires almost zero opex and capex to realize and doesn't cannibalize other efforts. 
  • Integrate it's DSL offer with it's mobile internet offer. Cheap or free access to 3G on the go is an offer the cable companies can't counter. It may cannibalize some of the 3G offers currently on the market. 
  • Include international calling in it's telephony offer. UPC is already offering this. Ziggo isn't yet. KPN could leverage it's position in iBasis to offer better deals. This does lead to some cannibalisation.
  • Provide free online backup. KPN already has an online backup service. It's €4.95 and the first 6 months free... It wouldn't be extremely hard to copy by other's but it's one of the very few services KPN could offer straight away


Wednesday, 2 December 2009

Posted more than a hundred times

Well, without even knowing it, I recently passed the 100 posts mark on this blog alone. I started March 2008. On my previous blog Lunaticthought I reached +/- 60. Here are some statistics I gathered from Google Analytics (why oh why doesn't analytics integrate with Feedburner) I want to give a great thanks to all my readers and I hope I can do another 100. These are the most popular pages


Page
Pageviews
Unique Pageviews
Homepage /
6347
4627
UPC Fiber Power Triumphant over KPN Fiber
1323
1045
The Telecom Cool Wall
1225
951
Etisalat and SS8 are hacking your Blackberry
919
738
Reggefiber to my Home
763
517
KPN and Reggefiber offer fiber for 12 euro
703
492
OECD Broadband stats infographic using Google graphs
525
440
PON vs P2P fiber topologies
462
288
Installation of FTTH in my home
396
157
Breaking news KPN and Reggefiber 7 billion investment in FTTH
342
273


These are the top referrers. Thanks to Sergej, Larry, Benoit, Tim, Stefano and James for their frequent links to me...

Source
Visits
google
6234
(direct)
3786
gathering.tweakers.net
578
google.com
465
twitter.com
301
fiberevolution.com
266
lunaticthought.blogspot.com
220
telcommunicator.blogspot.com
217
blog.quintarelli.it
211
eurotelcoblog.blogspot.com
197


The most popular browser is
Firefox
6,606
42.55%
Internet Explorer
6,437
41.46%
Safari
971
6.25%
Chrome
803
5.17%
Opera
322
2.07%

The Netherlands is the country with the most visits, like I would have expected, but India is an interesting one at the 9th place.


Country/Territory Visits
Netherlands 4311
United States 2547
United Kingdom 1686
Germany 677
Spain 660
Italy 559
France 491
Canada 377
India 297
Belgium 271

Wednesday, 25 November 2009

Maak breedbandmarkt innovatiever

In Dutch an opinion piece I wrote was published in "Het Financieele Dagblad". It is based on my Ecomm presentation, where I explain Free.fr's business model and philosophy. The point in the article is that Dutch broadband providers haven't innovated in the last 10 years and need to look at France to see how having only 1 product can lead to simplicity and alot of innovation. (Google Translate)


Maak breedbandmarkt innovatiever


De consument heeft genoeg van al die tientallen combinaties op het thema internet, tv en telefoon

Rudolf van der Berg



De triple play-strategie is aan een nieuwe impuls toe. Nederlandse aanbieders blijven steken in een verouderd model dat weinig zicht op vooruitgang biedt. De Franse markt toont dat het anders en goedkoper kan. Daar krijgt de klant een Mercedes voor de prijs van een Golf. Volgende week maandag 30 november is het tien jaar geleden dat KPN ADSL aankondigde in Nederland. Kabelaanbieders leverden al sinds 1995  internet zonder telefoontikken. Snel internet werd zo voor iedereen bereikbaar.
Qua internetpenetratie staat Nederland in de wereldtop. Maar het is verbazingwekkend te constateren dat in de afgelopen tien tot vijftien jaar de klant eigenlijk niets nieuws gekregen heeft. Iedere aanbieder komt met hetzelfde: internet, telefoon en televisie voor €20 tot €70. UPC heeft er 80 combinaties voor. Concurrentie tussen de twee infrastructuren leverde vooral meer bandbreedte en lagere prijzen op. Maar van echte innovatie is geen sprake.

Daar zijn twee oorzaken voor. Ten eerste ligt de nadruk op de verkeerde innovatie. Vol afgunst kijkt iedereen naar de marges van Google, Apple en Skype. Maar ondertussen vergeten ze dat die ene andere marktgigant Microsoft $4 mrd verloor op haar online diensten en de wereldwijde infrastructuur die daarvoor benodigd is.

Het succes van Google kopiëren zal niemand lukken. Een tweede fout is dat ze hun eigen bedrijfsvoering te complex maken door honderden combinaties van internet, telefonie en televisie aan te bieden. Vernieuwing is alleen al onbetaalbaar omdat het wijzigen van de systemen voor factureren en het onderhouden van klantenrelaties te complex is geworden.

Dat het ook anders kan bewijst de Franse breedbandmarkt. Deze is veel innovatiever. Alle aanbieders proberen er iedere paar maanden met iets nieuws te komen. Geen wereldschokkende diensten als Youtube,
maar wel innovaties waar de klant blij van wordt.

De aanstichter hiervoor is de nummer twee in de Franse markt: Free.fr . Dit bedrijf reduceerde alle complexiteit tot maar één aanbod en dat kost €30. De klant krijgt standaard de hoogste internetsnelheid, gratis bellen naar 100 landen en een uitgebreid pakket hd-tv.

De concurrentie vindt plaats op de gratis opties, zoals back-up, beveiligde toegang tot de wifi-verbinding van de 3 miljoen andere klanten van Free.Fr, spelletjes op de tv en zelfs voor iedere klant een eigen live tv-kanaal om wat dan ook uit te zenden. Concurrent SFR biedt vergelijkbare diensten en kwam met een gratis jukebox van 250.000 muzieknummers.

Vanuit het oogpunt van marketing kun je zeggen dat men in Frankrijk de T-Ford herontdekt heeft: Hij komt in alle kleuren als ie maar zwart is. Maar je zou ook kunnen zeggen dat ze je in Frankrijk een Mercedes met alle opties leveren voor de prijs van een Volkswagen Golf. Als de klant dan niet de stoelverwarming wil gebruiken, dan is dat zijn keuze, maar het zit er wel op en het kost niets meer.

Deze manier van concurrentie heeft als bijkomend voordeel dat de interne organisatie kan worden vereenvoudigd en gestroomlijnd. Zowel de IT-als de Sales-en Marketingafdelingen hoeven veel minder
complexiteit te managen. De gerealiseerde besparingen vinden hun weg terug in diensteninnovatie en ook in aandeelhouderswaarde. Wie is de eerste in Nederland die durft?

Rudolf van der Berg is Management Consultant van Logica Management Consulting.

Nederland staat met zijn internetpenetratie in de wereldtop, maar de klant heeft verder niets nieuws gekregen

In Frankrijk vindt concurrentie plaats op gratis opties zoals back-up en beveiligde toegang tot wifi

Tuesday, 24 November 2009

Pissing off the Peering Guru's.

This is one of the most hilarious threads on Gigaom for a long while. Richard Bennett (a guy who writes anything you pay him for) tried to bring paid peering into the net neutrality debate. It seems everybody is weighing in: Vijay Gill (Google), Patrick Gilmore (Akamai), Richard Steenbergen (nLayer) etc.

http://gigaom.com/2009/11/22/how-video-is-changing-the-internet/

Andrew Odlyzko should also have a look as his MINTS institute is given a snide remark as well.

All of it seems to have been the result of Bill Norton writing as Dr. Peering
http://drpeering.net/a/Ask_DrPeering/Entries/2009/11/5_Paid_Peering_and_Net_Neutrality.html

I respected Bill alot, but this piece is just off the mark. There seems no basis for it whatsoever.

and of course the obligatory link to my Peering and Transit introduction.

Update: CircleID also weighs in with: Dr. Peering commits malpractice on Net Neutrality.
http://www.circleid.com/posts/dr_peering_commits_malpractice_on_net_neutrality/

Tuesday, 17 November 2009

The Future of VoIP interconnection (or buy an ENUM-based number portability system now)

Last week I attended the ITU GSR09 in Lebanon as you might have guessed from previous posts. I presented a discussion paper there on the future of VoIP interconnection. I didn't like my paper too much as I thought I could have written down the point a lot more poignantly and used less deductive reasoning, however other people disagree. The presentation is now embedded below and the paper is available here.

The main point I think you should take away is that interconnection isn't that hard. It is made difficult by lawyers and weird business models, but it is quite simple. The second point is that regulators should have a look at ENUM for a national number database, with number portability attached to it. They shouldn't care about Public ENUM that much as it mixes technology and policy in standard. The policy who can change and add what in the national number database is the domain of the national regulators and not of the IETF or the ITU. BTW it turns out Bahrain is going to build a national number portability solution based on ENUM.

(And yes, Logica makes number portability systems, but that wasn't the reason why I came to my conclusion) 

A quick write up of the Dutch meeting on Net Neutrality

Two weeks ago the Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs organized a meeting on Net Neutrality. It was the third one already all presentations are now online. The first one was a more closed affair with economic thinktank Encore in 2006 (and a presentaton by moi)  and a more open meeting in 2007 similar to the one of Thursday. This time the occasion was the publication of a report by Dialogic on the topic. It's a very good report on net neutrality and worth the read. (It is in Dutch though)

The speakers at the meeting were:

  • Frank Heemskerk, deputy minister of Economic Affairs, (speech in English)
  • Taylor Reynolds, OECD
  • Rudi Bekkers, Dialogic, lead researcher for the report;
  • Michel van Eeten, professor TUDelft and Next Generation Infrastructures,
  • Alex Blowers, Ofcom, UK
  • Frode Sorensen, NPT, Norway 
  • Martijn van Dam, Member of Parliament for the Dutch Labour Party 
The speakers all had their interesting bits. Heemskerk was very polically vague about the topic, but not vague enough to not make sure everybody knew he wouldn't allow blatant violations of netneutrality, but where the line is is difficult. Rudi Bekkers gave a good overview of how it is very difficult to distinguish from an act that may harm netneutrality to derive the intent. Michel van Eeten was interesting as it showed how net neutrality was just a vague term that gives you a warm and fuzzy feeling. Martijn van Dam was excellent as a politician. He had a great opinion how everything should be open and freedom of speech etc. which is bound to be a press pleaser, but doesn't give you anything else. He also was of the opinion that the iPhone should be open and that companies should be barred from meddling with users rights (at which point Michel van Eeten pointed out that Van Dam is using an iPhone, hypocritical fool). Tad Reynolds showed how the debate was as much about competition as anything else. Frode Sorensen demonstrated the Norwegians ability to talk themselves out of any problem, just like the Dutch Poldermodel

I twittered the entire meeting, thanks to Swisscom who left a port open for free tweeting on their otherwise paid for wifi network.Unfortunately it seems that all is now lost as I didn't save them from Twitter.